Helen Frankenthaler, Untitled

In Helen Frankenthaler’s painting, a complex tension unfolds between the flatness of the picture surface and a sense of spatial depth, arising from the interplay of line and plane. After her marriage to Robert Motherwell in 1958, the couple visited the prehistoric caves of Lascaux in France and Altamira in Spain during their honeymoon – an experience that was to leave a lasting mark on Frankenthaler’s artistic development.

Her works from 1959 and 1960 long remained relatively overlooked and were only briefly discussed even in John Elderfield’s comprehensive monograph, despite representing a significant phase in her artistic evolution. As in Cave Memory (1959), now also part of the Reinhard Ernst Collection, these paintings bring together luminous opaque grounds and drawn lines on a single pictorial plane.

Helen Frankenthaler (1928–2011)

Untitled, 1959/60, 1959/60

Currently exhibited: Yes (Helen Frankenthaler moves Jenny Bronsinksi, Ina Gerken, Adrian Schiess)

Material: Oil and charcoal on canvas
Size: 228 x 177,6 cm
Inv-Nr.: B_577
Image rights: VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn; Copyright: Helen Frankenthaler Foundation, New York

Keywords:

Provenance

Previous owner: Helen Frankenthaler Foundation, New York;
Previous owner: Gagosian Gallery, Paris;
Previous owner: The Gerald Fineberg Collection
Acquisition: Reinhard Ernst Collection, 2023

Learn more

Characteristic of Frankenthaler’s painting during this period is the use of the three primary colors – blue, red, and yellow – in combination with earthy browns and blacks. At the same time, she began to move away from her signature soak-stain technique, allowing areas of paint to remain on a white-primed canvas. This heightened the brilliance of the colors, introduced passages of overpainting, and produced a more animated surface. This approach gives Untitled its distinctive force and sets it apart from the softer, absorbed hues of her earlier paintings.

According to Elderfield, Frankenthaler’s ‘rough and rowdy paintings’[1] of 1959-1960 formed the starting point for her quieter works of 1961–62. The spontaneous brushwork is deliberately conceived and remained central to Frankenthaler’s art throughout her life:

‘It is crucial to know when to stop. […] Very often the artist spells out for the viewer something that should instead, consciously or unconsciously, emerge through the whole. A painting, however elaborated, should retain a kind of immediacy, freshness, and concision that allow the viewer to complete the rest. If it is all spelled out, one often ends up with a very considered picture that betrays too much concern with its audience.’[2]

[1] John Elderfield, Think Though, Paint Though, Move On: Helen Frankenthaler. After Abstract Expressionism, 1959–1962, pp. 5–23, here p. 6.

[2] Quoted in ‘A Conversation: Helen Frankenthaler with Julia Brown’, in After Mountains and Sea: Frankenthaler 1956–1959, exh. cat. Guggenheim New York/Bilbao/Berlin, Ostfildern-Ruit 1998, pp. 29–49, here p. 38.

 

Literature references

John Elderfield, Think Though, Paint Though, Move On: Helen Frankenthaler. After Abstract Expressionism, 1959–1962, pp. 5–23, here p. 6.

‘A Conversation: Helen Frankenthaler with Julia Brown’, in After Mountains and Sea: Frankenthaler 1956–1959, exh. cat. Guggenheim New York/Bilbao/Berlin, Ostfildern-Ruit 1998, pp. 29–49, here p. 38.

Currently exhibited: Yes

Material: Oil and charcoal on canvas
Size: 228 x 177,6 cm
Inv-Nr.: B_577

Keywords: Abstract Expressionism, Color field painting, Soak-stain-technique